Wednesday, April 26, 2017

CNN's coverage of 9/11: it took several minutes for them to realize a second plane had hit; also "Soundtracks"


There is a lot of unauthorized video of the coverage of 9/11 from all the news services, so it’s good to find an original set of films owned by one of the networks.  Here is CNN’s own link ("Inside 9/11: The Day that Never Ends"), which shows that at first, people inside the North Tower had no real idea of what had happened.

CNN’s original coverage is curious.  It took about four minutes for the newscaster to realize a separate second plane had hit the South Tower.  And for a little while there was speculation about a “navigation error” rather than acceptance of terrorism. Most other networks immediately said that a second plane attack implied terrorism.

Donald Trump’s own reaction on 9/11 is in this video.

I was in my apartment in Minneapolis for about 15 minutes during the aftermath and saw the South Tower fall on ABC.



Update: April 27

CNN tonight aired the one-hour "Soundtracks: The Songs that Defined History" about the music world after 9/11.  Tribeca showed it (notes).

Springsteen appeared, but "We Are Family" got played.

Saturday, April 08, 2017

"Return to Mosul" on CNN: reporter returns to family that sheltered her from ISIS


Return to Mosul”, a one-hour special on CNN, aired 9 PM EDT Saturday April 8, 2017, shows correspondent Arwa Damon returning to visit the family she had sheltered in place with two months before in 2016 in Mosul, Iraq. The subtitle is "Return to Hell: Finding the Mosul Family Who Sheltered Us. 

I'm reminded immediately of the US Third Amendment about quartering soldiers (or maybe refugees).

Most of the soldiers were still there; one had lost an eye, another had recovered from leg wounds. But as she traveled around the city, she found it still very unsafe.

She visits eastern Mosul, which is supposed to be more liberated.

In one place, she found ruins of a makeshift plane intended as a kamikaze.  In another place, she encountered a family that had been recently forced to become human shields after an ISIS home invasion.

She visited a school that had recently opened, with male teachers trying to install something to live for, besides fundamentalism. She found wall art where images had been covered up by ISIS,  Cell phones, banned by ISIS, were returning.


I worked with a woman who had relatives in Mosul back on 2002 in Minneapolis, so I am only on degree of separation removed from all this.  Mosul has about the same population as Philadelphia.

About half of the buildings in the city looked flattened in to rubble.


Wikipedia attribution link for Voice of America picture of Eastern Mosul in 2016, p.d. 

Saturday, April 01, 2017

"ISIS: Under the Mask" examines a Catholic-turned-Muslim who left Belgium to join the group and returned


Friday night, March 31,  CNN broadcast “ISIS: Behind the Mask”, a special report with Clarissa Ward interviewing Michael Delefortrie, 28, now living in Belgium, who was raised as Catholic but left Belgium to go to Syria and fight with ISIS in his mid twenties and returned.

European authorities are very concerned about returned fighters.  But except for a brief jail sentence, Michael has stayed out of trouble.  He uses Europe's free speech to spread his ideas.  He also happily excepts welfare from the state for income.

“I am not a Belgian, I am a Muslim”, he maintains.

He denied killing anyone while with ISIS and says he will not use violence at home.

However, he wants Europe and the U.S. and the entire world to be brought under Sharia law.



He did start using drugs and getting bad grades in school as a teen.  Muslim laws seemed to give him an absolute sense of morality and a group to belong to.

He regards Osama bin Laden as a hero, and says historical figures should not be downgraded in judgement for killing people.

In general young men (and women) with some petty crime and drug use and a psychology of wanting to fit in to a warrior group sound more vulnerable to cult-like radicalization.  Also relevant is a desire to see others have to follow the same rules of living that they think have been imposed on them, as this seems to make their lives (and potential marital relationships) more exciting and meaningful.

Micheal is married and wants his son to be a fighter. The documentary mentioned some domestic abuse. He is tall, slender, very "white", and wears a beard without mustache.

Michael spoke in absolute terms, that everything is for Allah and that Allah alone will judge whether the violent actions of people suit His purposed.  He did not question why one source of scriptural authority (like the Koran) is more valid than another (the Bible). He showed no sense of epistemology.

Later the broadcast showed an experiment with recruiting online.  CNN went undercover and got 223 strangers wanting to be “friends”, from Belgium and France.  Several wanted to go underground with conversations on Telegram .   Seeker has an article on this matter here.

There was discussion of “Sharia4Beligum”.

Wikipedia attribution link for  Atomium in Brussels,    under CCSA 3.0.